Now that the government says it’s going to try to make it harder for kids to get E-cigarettes, one question that some people are asking is whether the FDA is doing enough.
The Food And Drug Administration’s new proposal says that companies will have to submit E-cigarette products for review by August 8, 2021, instead of by 2022. The FDA also says the government will be able to step in at any time to:
- Limit online vendors from selling without without a “heightened age verification process.”
- Limit sales in brick-and-mortar vendors without age restrictions.
- Limit sale of products specifically aimed at young people.
According to Dr. Shelley, it’s mostly a problem with misinformation. Kids understand cigarettes are bad for them, so they don’t smoke. “Kids are really under the misconception that this is just a cool thing to do the same way we were with cigarettes fifty years ago. Back then nobody thought cigarettes were going to be dangerous,” she says. “But if [the FDA] continues on the path, kids are smart, we are hoping kids will see these ads.”
What worked best with cigarettes was a campaign about telling the truth, according to Dr. Shelley. “It worked for cigarettes because it was really a truth campaign. That's what was so successful – ‘this industry is manipulating you.’ ‘Real cost’ is very much about the truth, just like the truth campaign which was remarkably successful. We have a lot of information about product regulation and counter advertising.”
But it’s a difficult process, and a lot of steps that were taken for cigarettes have yet to be implemented for E-cigarettes. “For cigarettes we have a ban on any advertising having cartoon characters, advertising directed specifically toward kids. They haven't banned that yet [for E-cigarettes], but I think we're moving toward that,” she says.
And now, the tobacco industry could be getting involved with E-cigarettes. “We're playing catch up with this product, and I think the most concerning thing is that the tobacco industry is getting into this business. Altria just invested $12 million in JUUL. They know how to get kids addicted to nicotine. JUUL was definitely advertising to kids. It really escalated the problem because of the brilliant design and the ad campaigns.” Altria is the manufacturer that makes Marlboro and Virginia Slims.
Through social media and other tools, the anti JUUL campaign has had some success, according to Dr. Shelley. “The FDA has actually done an amazing job, given how long it can take for the government to act, moving programs out the door. They have in a very short time developed a very effective campaign, using trials, research, etc. called the ‘real cost.’ They put that together pretty rapidly and they are finding that the reach is high. Through social media and other tools they are really getting the message out.”
But it’s important not to make vaping or JUUL a point of shame for people who do have lung cancer, according to Dr. Brendan Stiles, Thoracic Surgeon at Weill Cornell Medicine and NewYork-Presbyterian. "I certainly don't give my patients a hard time if they're vaping; I actually don't give them a hard time if they're still smoking," says Dr. Stiles. "It's very, very hard to quit, and they've got so many things going through their mind and so much anxiety at the time of their surgery that I don't have a policy, 'hey, gotta stop smoking.' I think surgery is a great learning opportunity, it's a great time for them to be in the hospital where hopefully they'll stop after that. But, it's tough to really beat people up about that in my opinion."
Efforts to stem vaping among young people, though, are important and difficult to pursue. Likening the process to “whack-a-mole,” Dr. Shelley says that the government is pleading with big vendors. “Every time they send someone to a particular company, they are telling that companyEbay, Walgreens– to stop selling these products to kids. It's like whack-a-mole, but they are very aggressively trying to get companies to stop selling.”
Dr. Shelley emphasized the role that local governments can have in the campaign against E-cigarettes for kids. “We have a law in New York City now that cigarettes have to be behind the counter now, so kids can't lift them, and there have been other measures in the city too. We have a 21 year old law for cigarettes, and thats true for E-cigarettes too,” she says. “The FDA cannot solve this alone. It has to be at a grass roots level as well. We have a license law in New York City, and if [vendors] are caught in stings, they can lose their license. And now the city has put a tax on the cigarette juice as well. So there are state and city laws that can be passed. But it's best when the government does it because it’s one fell swoop.”
But she also called for more research, which would help the government parse out which flavors put kids at the highest risk, and which might be useful for adults. “We really need more science on which flavors attract kids, and don't attract kids so that maybe adults could keep those flavors… Flavors are whats attracting them to kids there's no questions.”
“I was disappointed that the commissioner stepped down, because they are trying very aggressively to restrict JUUL," says Dr. Shelley about commissioner Scott Gottlieb’s sudden retirement announcement. “I don't know what's going to happen with the change in leadership, but the team that is working on the product is extremely experienced.”
Learn more about SurvivorNet's rigorous medical review process.